The rise and fall of Seneca Mall in West Seneca near Buffalo, NY, and the long wait over the land it left behind

Hengerer's and JCPenney rise beside the Thruway

Through 1968, Hengerer's went up at the Ridge Road end of a 51-acre construction site in West Seneca, and JCPenney at the end nearer Orchard Park Road.

The ground lay just east of the New York State Thruway, near Exit 55, closed in by Orchard Park Road, Ridge Road, Slade Avenue, and a railroad line.

Across Orchard Park Road sat the Blatt Brothers' Park Drive-In. Plans called for 53 stores, and the job was one of the biggest started anywhere in Western New York that year.

Seneca Mall demolition in West Seneca near Buffalo, NY

A bank had been lined up long before the site was dug.

In August 1966 the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors approved a Marine Midland branch at "Seneca Mall," a shopping center that so far existed only as a plan.

In July 1967 the Federal Reserve Bank of New York extended Marine Midland's deadline, giving the bank until March 1969 to open the branch.

Seneca Mall opens with three department stores

Seneca Mall opened in spring 1969 in the Town of West Seneca, New York, just south of Buffalo, as an enclosed one-story regional mall of about 700,000 square feet.

Three department stores carried it. Hengerer's held one end and JCPenney the other, and Sattler's opened a new store of its own.

Alongside them came three smaller anchors: L.L. Berger, which opened its Seneca Mall store that year, Kleinhans, and The Sample, whose newspaper advertising in early May 1969 already sent shoppers to the new mall.

At the middle of the building, the central court was built around a large round fireplace.

The Thruway ran right past the site and gave the mall a direct road to the whole region.

In July 1970 West Seneca set rules for a traffic signal on Slade Avenue, where the mall's parking-lot driveways met the road opposite the driveway of an Erie County Savings Bank branch.

The light was worked by detectors, which gave the green to cars pulling out of the mall.

Seneca Mall draws shoppers, then loses Sattler's

Seneca Mall quickly altered the retail map.

In Cheektowaga, Thruway Plaza, an early landmark of suburban shopping in the region, felt the pressure after the mall opened in 1969.

Sattler's had a store there as well, and in 1972 it closed it, in part because its new Seneca Mall store stood so close. The city felt it too.

In South Buffalo, the City of Buffalo approved an urban-renewal plan for the Seneca-Cazenovia commercial district in 1980, with Seneca Mall and Southgate Plaza identified as major sources of suburban competition.

When the Census Bureau counted the country's retail trade for 1982, it treated Seneca Mall and the businesses packed around it, inside the same ring of roads and rail, as one of the area's major retail centers.

That same year the mall lost a department store. On January 25, 1982, the Sattler's at Seneca Mall closed.

Its parent company, United Department Stores, had gone bankrupt, and Sattler's shut five of its six Western New York stores that same day, from Main Place Mall in Buffalo to Olean and Jamestown.

Between 200 and 250 employees across the chain were left unsure of their jobs.

The store at the Ridge Road end changed in the same years without closing: in the early 1980s, Hengerer's became Sibley's.

The anchors leave and the mall comes down

Two newer malls arrived in the 1980s. McKinley Mall opened in Hamburg in 1985 and was the first serious hit to Seneca Mall.

Walden Galleria followed in May 1989, in Cheektowaga, with more regional chains among its stores than Seneca Mall had.

It belonged to Pyramid Companies, and several of Seneca Mall's biggest tenants went there.

The Sample was one of them, opening a Galleria store.

The Galleria's opening sped up Seneca Mall's end.

Within about a year, Sibley's, JCPenney, The Sample, and Kleinhans had all shut their Seneca Mall stores, and L.L. Berger was among the local retailers that left their older locations around the Galleria's opening.

With Sattler's already gone, that was every department store and every smaller anchor the mall had opened with.

Losing that many large stores at once left the mall with no department store to draw anyone in, and the building mostly empty.

By the mall's last years, Pyramid controlled Seneca Mall as well.

The doors stayed open after the stores left. In October 1990 the building still stood, and the public could still walk in.

For several years in the early 1990s, it was used mostly as an indoor track for walkers.

Seneca Mall closed in 1994, 25 years after it opened, and most of the building came down the same year.

Clearing the smaller buildings and parcels around it took longer.

Nothing of the enclosed mall was kept, and whatever came next would be built new.

Seneca Mall in West Seneca near Buffalo, NY
Seneca Mall in West Seneca near Buffalo, NY

Tops opens on the old mall land

Once the mall was gone, Pyramid proposed a power center for the land, a cluster of big stores in separate buildings that went by the name Shops at West Seneca.

Tops Friendly Markets opened the first of them at 355 Orchard Park Road on May 18, 1997. A Kmart came later, in a building of its own.

That was as far as the plan got. Pyramid drew up other versions over the years, and each one stopped on paper.

Through the 2000s most of the land where the mall had stood was fenced off, and parts of it held stored material and fill.

The town's comprehensive plan from that decade treated the property as a problem to solve and asked for its zoning to be switched from industrial to commercial.

In 2016 the town tried a different picture: a walkable lifestyle center, with shops, offices, homes, and public space laid out on smaller blocks.

Neither town plan was built while Pyramid owned the site.

Tops stayed, and so did the old name.

In 2018 the chain's store list still filed the location under "Seneca Mall," and the store was open 24 hours. Kmart closed in early 2019.

In February 2020 crews began tearing down its empty building, by then one of only a few left standing on land that was otherwise mostly bare.

The old mall land goes up for sale

In January 2020, West Seneca's new town supervisor named the redevelopment of the site a top priority.

By 2024 the Chamber of Commerce was asking Pyramid in public to sell, and the town was looking at its legal options.

In June 2024 a member of the Town Board formally asked the board to have the town attorney study every option for the property, which had sat mostly vacant for three decades.

Pyramid listed the 55 acres for sale that summer.

A former bank building on a separate parcel at 325 Orchard Park Road sold first, to Community Bank, for $1.5 million.

The main sales closed in December 2024 and split the land in two.

Benchmark Streamline, an affiliate of Amherst-based Benchmark Group, bought 12 vacant parcels, about 48 acres, for $8 million.

NS Retail Holdings, which uses the Dallas address of NETSTREIT Corp., paid $13.9 million for the roughly seven acres under the Tops store.

Together the two deals came to about $22 million.

A new shopping center is planned for the land

Benchmark called its project West Seneca Exchange and filed its first plans in March 2025.

They showed a pair of big anchor stores, one of roughly 181,000 square feet and one of roughly 120,000, two smaller buildings of about 15,000 square feet each, and seven outparcels for restaurants, a bank, or shops.

No tenants were named. Finished, the whole project was put at more than $100 million.

In May 2025 the Town Board voted 5-0 to rezone the land to a commercial district that allows gas pumps and drive-thru restaurants, the kind of commercial zoning the town's own plan had recommended years before.

The plan before the board covered a 56-acre area and planned roughly 500,000 more square feet of commercial floor space and room for about 2,700 cars, next to the 92,000-square-foot Tops.

It also called for new turn lanes on Slade Avenue, signal improvements, and changes to the Route 219 off-ramp.

In June 2025, Community Bank opened a branch in its building on Orchard Park Road.

By the end of 2025, the new owners had started preparing the property.

Costco is picked as the new anchor

In 2026, 64,000 cubic yards of fill came onto the land, a large share of it from the construction of the new Highmark Stadium.

The fill went down as temporary weight, to press the ground firm before any building goes up, and it is meant to be spread out once the ground has settled.

In July 2026 the town supervisor announced Costco as the anchor tenant.

Traffic, drainage, and the soil were the questions raised as the plans went to the town Planning Board, and in August 2026 the board signed off on the site plan for the whole project and on the Costco plan, on the condition that town engineering requirements are met and the state transportation department approves the road work.

The approved layout puts a Costco warehouse store, planned on about 18 acres, at the center, with 16 more retail spaces, restaurants, a gas station, new internal roads, new traffic signals and turn lanes, and sidewalks.

Benchmark has set the second quarter of 2027 for the start of main construction and expects the job to take about two years.

The old Seneca Mall land is on its way to becoming a Costco-led shopping center called West Seneca Exchange, but none of its new buildings stand yet, and the main construction has not begun.

In the early 1990s, walkers had the emptied corridors of Seneca Mall to themselves.

The land under the old mall now carries an approved site plan for a Costco and no building yet, and Tops, open since 1997, is the store trading there.

Independent Publisher Notice

BestAttractions is an independent editorial publisher. We are not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any location, business, property owner, manager, government agency, or organization described in this article. Comments posted on this page are not forwarded to, reviewed by, or acted upon by any entity mentioned in the article. For official inquiries, complaints, applications, bookings, or other requests, please contact the relevant entity directly through its official website or other verified channels.

Add a comment


More from New York State