The Point at Carlisle Plaza Mall: Carlisle, PA’s Landmark in Trouble

The Early Years of The Point at Carlisle Plaza

In the heart of Carlisle, Pennsylvania, a bustling open-air shopping plaza emerged in 1964. Known as Carlisle Plaza, it was a symbol of innovation and community gathering. Backed by David Javitch, the founder of Giant Food Stores, and his son Lee, the plaza was a beacon of commerce and social interaction.

The plaza’s early years were marked by growth and ambition. In 1968, plans to transform the plaza into an enclosed mall were unveiled, with Crown American Realty Trust overseeing the ownership. The community buzzed with excitement as the vision of a modern shopping destination began to take shape.

By 1976, the transformation was complete. The once open-air plaza had become an enclosed mall, reflecting the changing retail and consumer behavior trends. The enlarged and enclosed mall became a hub for shopping, dining, and entertainment, attracting visitors from near and far.

Expansion and Transformation

The mall’s success continued to soar in the following decades. Crown American’s stewardship saw further growth and development, turning the mall into a landmark in Carlisle.

However, change was on the horizon, and in November 2002, the mall was sold to Michael Joseph Development Corporation for $5.8 million.

The new ownership brought fresh ideas and a renewed vision for the mall. The mall was renamed The Point at Carlisle Plaza in August 2003 and underwent significant reconfiguration. Two anchor buildings were removed, and 200,000 sq ft of space was reimagined, paving the way for new opportunities and experiences.

A mural depicting the history of Carlisle had to be relocated before construction, symbolizing the mall’s connection to the community’s heritage. The renovations, costing $4 million, were a bold step towards modernization, reflecting the evolving needs of shoppers and retailers alike.

Renaming and Reconfiguration

The early 2000s were a time of change and reinvention for The Point at Carlisle Plaza. The renaming marked a new era, and the reconfiguration was a strategic move to adapt to the changing retail landscape.

Removing two anchor buildings, formerly occupied by Albion Point Antiques & Collectibles/Kmart and J.C. Penney, created space for new ventures. Lowe’s opened on the former space in February 2004, adding a new dimension to the mall’s offerings.

The reconfiguration was not just about physical changes but about reimagining the mall’s identity and positioning it for future success. The mall’s renovations were a testament to its resilience and adaptability, qualities that would serve it well in the future.

New Ownership and Developments

In August 2005, Cedar Carlisle LLC purchased the mall for $11 million, ushering in a new phase of growth and development. Dunham’s Sports opened at the mall in late September 2005, adding to the diverse mix of stores and services.

Giant (Point Plaza LLC) purchased the mall for $7.35 million in October 2012, marking another significant milestone in the mall’s history. The ownership changes were more than mere transactions; they were strategic moves that shaped the mall’s direction and future.

The mall continued to evolve, reflecting the trends and preferences of shoppers. Yet, it never lost its connection to the community, where memories were made and experiences were shared.

Recent Changes and Challenges

The Point at Carlisle Plaza faced challenges and changes in recent years. The closing of the Bon-Ton store in late January 2018 was a significant event, signaling shifts in the retail landscape. The former Bon-Ton space found a new purpose in January 2019, used to store new Giant shopping carts.

Despite the challenges, the mall remained a vibrant part of Carlisle’s fabric. Its ability to adapt and reinvent was a testament to its enduring appeal and relevance.

The mall’s journey was about commerce, community, connection, and continuity. It was where generations of Carlisle residents shopped, dined, and celebrated life’s milestones.

The Impact on the Community

The Point at Carlisle Plaza was more than a shopping destination; it was a part of Carlisle’s identity. Its evolution from an open-air plaza to a modern mall mirrored the growth and transformation of the community itself.

The mall’s impact extended beyond retail. It was a gathering place, a hub for social interaction, and a symbol of Carlisle’s progress and ambition. Its changes, challenges, and successes were intertwined with the lives of those who called Carlisle home.

The memories created within its walls were cherished by many, reflecting the mall’s unique place in the hearts and minds of Carlisle residents. Its story was not just about business but about people, relationships, and a shared sense of belonging.


The Point at Carlisle Plaza’s story is a complex tapestry of growth, transformation, and challenges. However, the mall now faces significant troubles; almost empty, with numerous closed stores.

Its current state is a reflection of broader trends in retail and a symbol of the challenges faced by shopping centers across the nation. Despite its struggles, the mall’s legacy remains firmly rooted in the community’s history. It is a nostalgic reminder of what once was and, perhaps, a hopeful vision of what could be with the exemplary revitalization efforts.

The Point at Carlisle Plaza is not just a building; it’s a part of Carlisle’s identity, filled with memories and experiences. Its story is a testament to the ever-changing nature of community spaces and a poignant reminder of the importance of adaptation and resilience.

Avatar of Spencer Walsh

I'm Spencer Walsh, a professional traveler who loves to help people discover new places and learn about different cultures. I've traveled worldwide, from Europe to Asia and Africa to South America. My favorite thing about traveling is getting lost because it allows me to discover unexpected gems—finding a hidden museum or stumbling upon a beautiful park in the middle of the city.

Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: