Castleton Square Mall in Indianapolis, IN: A Hub of Fashion and Fun

The Genesis of Castleton Square Mall

Castleton Square Mall, nestled in the vibrant city of Indianapolis, Indiana, stands as a testament to the evolution of retail spaces over the decades.

Officially opened to the public on September 13, 1972, it has since become a cornerstone of shopping and leisure in the region.

As of 2023, Castleton Square continues to thrive as the largest mall in Indiana, a proudly held title since its inception.

Developers and Early Design

The mall’s journey began with the vision of the Edward J. DeBartolo Corporation and Homart Development Company, two giants in the realm of commercial real estate.

Their collaborative efforts laid the foundation for a premier shopping destination.

The design and construction of the mall were driven by a forward-thinking approach, aiming to create a space that was not just a collection of stores but a hub of community activity and engagement.

Initial Anchor Stores and Features

From the outset, Castleton Square was destined to be a landmark. It originally featured major anchor stores such as Lazarus, Sears, JCPenney, and Woolworths.

These anchors were more than just stores; they were key attractions that drew crowds across Indianapolis and beyond.

The mall’s architectural design included elements like a 20-foot-wide fountain, elegant chandeliers in the center court, and an array of live tropical plants, creating an inviting and sophisticated atmosphere.

Including over 100 circular benches, skylights, and terrazzo flooring further enhanced the shopping experience, making it a preferred destination for things to do in Indianapolis, Indiana.

Its rich history and ongoing appeal, Castleton Square symbolizes Indianapolis retail resilience and innovation.

The 1970s and 1980s – Foundational Years

The Inaugural Decade: Establishing a Retail Landmark

Upon its grand opening, Castleton Square Mall, sprawling over 1,116,000 square feet, claimed the title of the largest mall in Indiana.

USA Quiz

How many questions would you like?

Your result:
Comment based on score

The first store to welcome shoppers was Sears in August 1972, marking the beginning of the mall’s storied journey.

The official opening ceremonies on September 13, 1972, led by Indianapolis Mayor Richard Lugar, were a significant milestone.

By Christmas that year, the mall’s store count had impressively grown to 59, including the opening of JCPenney in January 1973 and Woolworth in March.

In August 1973, Lazarus opened its first Indiana store in the mall, featuring three levels and a restaurant with a view of the center court.

This opening, attended by William P. Giovanello, then-president of Lazarus, was a testament to the mall’s growing prominence.

Evolving Retail Landscape

The mid-1970s saw General Cinema Corporation expand its footprint with a second cinema, further diversifying the mall’s entertainment offerings.

However, the late 1970s and early 1980s brought changes; Kroger relocated in 1979, and Woolworth closed in 1982.

The vacated Woolworth space briefly transformed into a showroom for local automotive dealers during the 1982 Christmas season.

A New Era of Renovations and Additions

In 1983, a significant renovation was announced by Edward J. DeBartolo Corporation. This renovation included new planters, benches, and the transformation of the central fountain into a performance stage.

The mall also saw enhancements in lighting, heightened ceilings in department stores, and the addition of a customer service kiosk.

Kohl’s opened in the former Woolworth space, marking its entry into Indianapolis. The mall’s tenth anniversary was celebrated with over fifty circus performers, highlighting the mall’s commitment to providing a unique and engaging shopping experience.

The 1990s – A Decade of Significant Growth

Introduction of New Anchor Stores

The 1990s were a transformative period for Castleton Square, marked by the introduction of new anchor stores that reshaped its retail landscape.

In August 1990, L. S. Ayres opened a 150,000-square-foot prototype store, targeting customers from northeastern Indianapolis and beyond.

Following this, in October 1990, a 108,000-square-foot Montgomery Ward department store commenced operations, further diversifying the mall’s retail offerings.

Mall Expansion and Renovations

This decade also witnessed significant physical expansions and renovations. The mall extended its footprint to accommodate the growing number of stores and services.

These expansions added space and enhanced the shopping experience with modern designs and updated facilities.

The introduction of a Best Buy store 1992 adjacent to the mall further solidified its status as a retail powerhouse.

Retail Landscape Changes

The 1990s saw a dynamic shift in the retail industry, with Castleton Square at the forefront of adapting to these changes.

The mall focused on diversifying its retail mix and introducing new brands and concepts to meet evolving consumer preferences.

This approach helped the mall maintain relevance and appeal in a rapidly changing retail environment.

The 21st Century – Modern Transformations

Rebranding and New Additions

The turn of the century brought significant changes to Castleton Square, beginning with the rebranding of Lazarus to Lazarus-Macy’s in 2003.

This strategic move was part of Federated Department Stores’ nationwide effort to expand the Macy’s brand.

The same year witnessed the expansion of Galyan’s building, adding 20,000 square feet to its retail space.

In 2004, Galyan’s transitioned to Dick’s Sporting Goods, reflecting the dynamic nature of retail trends.

Renovations and Additions

2006, the L. S. Ayres store was closed and demolished for a new outdoor concourse.

This area now features popular destinations like AMC Theatres, Johnny Rockets, and H&M, adding a fresh dimension to the mall’s appeal.

The closure of Borders in 2011 paved the way for a larger Forever 21 store, keeping the mall’s retail offerings in line with current trends.

Impact of Online Retail

The later 2010s also saw the rise of online retail, presenting new challenges for traditional shopping malls.

Castleton Square responded by enhancing the shopping experience with modern amenities and services.

This included introducing mobile payment options and dedicated areas for online pickups and returns, catering to the evolving needs of the digital-age consumer.

Current Anchors and Their Stories


Macy’s at Castleton Square, originally Lazarus, has been a cornerstone of the mall’s retail offerings.

The store’s evolution from Lazarus to Lazarus-Macy’s, and finally to Macy’s, reflects the broader trends in department store branding and consumer preferences.

Today, Macy’s remains a key anchor, drawing shoppers with its wide range of products and iconic brand presence.


JCPenney, an original tenant since the mall’s opening in 1972, has remained a constant in the ever-changing retail landscape of Castleton Square.

Its longevity and adaptability have made it a familiar and trusted destination for generations of shoppers.

Dick’s Sporting Goods

Dick’s Sporting Goods at Castleton Square symbolizes the mall’s commitment to meeting the diverse needs of its patrons.

Occupying the space previously held by Galyan’s, Dick’s Sporting Goods offers a comprehensive range of sporting apparel, equipment, and accessories.

This store caters to sports enthusiasts of all ages and skill levels, making it a go-to destination for fitness and outdoor activities.

Its presence in the mall underscores the importance of sports and wellness in the modern consumer lifestyle.

Von Maur

With its opening in 1998, Von Maur brought a touch of elegance and upscale shopping to Castleton Square.

Known for its wide selection of high-quality brands, exceptional customer service, and an aesthetically pleasing shopping environment, Von Maur offers a unique department store experience.

It stands out for its commitment to providing a luxurious shopping experience, making it a favorite among shoppers seeking quality and style.


H&M, a global leader in fashion retail, offers trendy and affordable clothing at Castleton Square.

Since its introduction, H&M has become a magnet for fashion-forward shoppers, particularly young adults and teens.

The store’s constantly updated inventory, featuring the latest in fashion trends, ensures that it remains a popular destination for those looking to stay ahead in the fashion game.

Forever 21

Forever 21 at Castleton Square caters to the fashion-conscious and budget-aware shopper.

Known for its trendy clothing and accessories at affordable prices, Forever 21 has become a staple for young shoppers.

The store’s dynamic approach to fast fashion keeps it at the forefront of the latest styles, making it a go-to spot for those seeking contemporary fashion without breaking the bank.

AMC Theatres 

AMC Theatres adds an entertainment dimension to Castleton Square, transforming it into more than just a shopping destination.

With the latest movie releases and state-of-the-art facilities, AMC Theatres provides a top-tier cinematic experience.

It’s a popular spot for families, friends, and movie buffs, offering an enjoyable escape into the world of film right within the convenience of the mall.

Crime and Security in Recent Years

Recent Incidents and Security Concerns

Unfortunately, Castleton Square has not been immune to the darker side of society.

The mall has experienced a series of violent incidents over the years, which have left a lasting impact on the community.

In January 2023, a juvenile was killed, and a man was injured in a shooting outside the mall; the following month, an 18-year-old was shot inside the foyer area.

Enhanced Security Measures

These tragic events led to public concern and sparked a discussion on safety measures at the mall.

In response, Castleton Square and its parent company, Simon Property Group, implemented new security upgrades in March 2023.

The measures included license plate reading cameras at parking entrances and additional parking lot towers with live-view cameras.

These measures aim to provide shoppers and staff with a safe and secure environment, ensuring that the mall remains a welcoming place for all.

Community and Shopper Reactions

The mall’s management aims to push people with “bad intentions” elsewhere, ensuring a safe and welcoming environment for shoppers and visitors.

While the shooting incidents represent a dark chapter in the history of Castleton Square, the mall’s decisive actions to improve security and prioritize visitor safety demonstrate its commitment to providing a secure shopping experience for the community.

The community’s reaction to these incidents has been one of resilience and support. Shoppers continue to frequent the mall, albeit with a heightened awareness of their surroundings.

The mall’s efforts to strengthen security have been well-received, reinforcing the community’s trust and confidence in the mall as a safe shopping and leisure destination.


Reflecting on Castleton Square Mall’s Journey

Over the years, Castleton Square has evolved from a simple shopping center to a comprehensive retail and entertainment hub.

Its journey, marked by expansions, renovations, and the introduction of diverse retail and entertainment options, reflects the dynamic nature of the retail industry.

The mall has adapted to changing consumer preferences and technological advancements, maintaining its position as a premier shopping destination in Indianapolis.

The Mall’s Ongoing Appeal and Future Prospects

Today, Castleton Square is a testament to the resilience and adaptability of traditional retail spaces in the face of evolving market trends.

With its diverse range of stores, from anchor tenants like Macy’s and JCPenney to popular outlets like H&M and Forever 21, the mall continues to attract a wide spectrum of shoppers.

Adding entertainment options like AMC Theatres further enhances its appeal as a multifaceted destination.

Looking Ahead

As Castleton Square looks to the future, it remains committed to evolving, continually seeking ways to improve the shopping experience and adapt to new retail trends.

Its ongoing efforts to ensure safety and security and its dedication to providing a diverse and enjoyable shopping experience position it well for continued success in the years to come.

With its rich history and forward-looking approach, Castleton Square is set to remain a key player in Indianapolis’s retail landscape.

Bundle your hotel + flight together to save more on your next trip! Book now at Expedia.comp565drvjpn8A99EIBAEG8ADCHCIBI website participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program allows sites to earn advertising fees through links to Amazon products at no additional cost to you. Amazon and the Amazon logo are registered trademarks of, Inc., or its affiliates.

Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: