What Happened to Philadelphia Mills Mall? A Look at its Declining Fortunes in Philadelphia, PA

Unfolding the Pages: The History and Changes

Once a bustling hub of activity, Philadelphia Mills Mall has seen better days. Opened on May 11, 1989, the mall was initially named Franklin Mills, a nod to one of America’s founding fathers, Benjamin Franklin. Developed by the Mills Corporation, the mall was a retail marvel in its heyday, attracting shoppers from all corners of Philadelphia and beyond.

The mall’s design was iconic, inspired by Benjamin Franklin’s famous kite-and-key experiment. Shaped like a thunderbolt, the mall was divided into four neighborhoods—Red, Blue, Yellow, and Green—each with its own unique set of stores and attractions.

In 2014, the Simon Property Group, which had taken over the mall’s management, decided to rename it Philadelphia Mills, aligning the mall more closely with its home city.

But names and designs are just part of the story. What set the mall apart was its tenant mix. The mall had something for everyone, from high-end fashion outlets to cozy bookstores. Over the years, however, the retail landscape shifted, and the mall started showing signs of aging.

The Pillars of the Mall: The Anchor Tenants

The anchor stores have always been the backbone of Philadelphia Mills. In its prime, the mall boasted diverse anchors, from JCPenney and Sears to Ports of the World and Phar-Mor. These stores were the big draws, pulling in crowds and setting the tone for the shopping experience.

However, the mall has not been immune to the retail apocalypse that has swept across America. Some anchor stores—Phar-Mor, JCPenney, and Modell’s Sporting Goods—have closed. The loss of these anchors has had a ripple effect, leading to reduced foot traffic and affecting the smaller tenants that relied on the anchors to draw crowds.

The remaining anchors are trying to adapt to the changing retail landscape. Some, like Walmart and AMC Theatres, have revamped their offerings to cater to a more experience-focused consumer. Sears store was rebranded as American Freight, and Ports became Boscov’s and was later replaced by Steve & Barry’s. Others, like Burlington and Turn 7, have doubled down on discounts and deals to attract budget-conscious shoppers.

A Kaleidoscope of Stores: The Tenant Landscape

The retail offerings at Philadelphia Mills are a mixed bag, reflecting its attempts to adapt to changing consumer preferences and challenges. Stores like Calvin Klein and Tommy Hilfiger offer brand-name fashion, while outlets like Famous Footwear and Finish Line cater to those seeking athletic wear and shoes. For tech-savvy shoppers, GameStop provides a haven for video games and electronics.

Yet, despite these diverse offerings, the mall struggles to maintain a vibrant tenant landscape. Specialty stores like Kay Jewelers Outlet and Harry’s Fragrance Outlet have managed to carve out a niche, offering unique products that aren’t easily found online. These stores serve a loyal customer base, providing a glimmer of hope in an otherwise challenging retail environment.

However, the mall also has its share of vacant storefronts, a testament to its ongoing struggles. Stores like Bed, Bath and Beyond, Neiman Marcus Last Call, and many smaller ones have closed down, leaving empty spaces contributing to the mall’s overall sense of decline. These vacancies affect the mall’s aesthetics and ability to attract new tenants and shoppers.

In summary, while Philadelphia Mills has a range of stores that should, theoretically, cater to a broad spectrum of shoppers, the reality is less rosy. The mall’s tenant landscape is a patchwork of successes and failures, reflecting brick-and-mortar retail’s broader challenges today.

The Culinary Landscape: Dining Options at Philadelphia Mills

The dining scene at Philadelphia Mills is a reflection of its overall condition. With a limited number of food outlets, the mall’s culinary offerings can best be described as meager, especially for a shopping center of its size. Gone are the days when the food court was a bustling hub of activity, filled with an array of options that catered to diverse tastes and preferences.

Among the current dining options, Auntie Anne’s Pretzels and Cinnabon offer quick bites for those with a sweet tooth. Charleys Cheesesteaks and Popeye’s Chicken provide fast-food staples for those looking for a more substantial fare.

Dave & Buster’s Grand Sports Café stands out as a place where visitors can enjoy food and entertainment under one roof. Caribbean Paradise and Zara Halal Grill represent ethnic flavors, while Little Tokyo offers a taste of Japanese cuisine. Rita’s Italian Ice and Great American Cookies have you covered for dessert or a refreshing treat.

The dining options, or lack thereof, at Philadelphia Mills, raise questions about the mall’s ability to attract and retain visitors. A mall is not just a place for shopping; it’s also a social gathering spot, and food plays a significant role in that experience.

The Sunset Years: The Decline

Philadelphia Mills has faced a series of setbacks, from the loss of anchor tenants to a decline in overall foot traffic. But perhaps the most telling signs of the mall’s decline are the incidents that have marred its reputation.

In recent years, the mall has been the site of several unfortunate events, from fights and robberies to shooting. These incidents have raised safety concerns and further deterred shoppers from visiting. The COVID-19 pandemic dealt another blow to the mall, forcing it to shut down temporarily and leading to further declining foot traffic.

The mall’s parent company, Simon, closed all its malls nationwide during the pandemic, including Philadelphia Mills. While the mall has since reopened, the scars of the past few years remain visible. Stores are struggling to attract customers.

What Lies Ahead: The Future Outlook

While Philadelphia Mills has faced its share of challenges, it’s important to remember that it remains a functioning retail space with potential for revival.

The mall’s prime location in Northeast Philadelphia, bordering Bensalem in Bucks County, gives it a geographical advantage that could be leveraged for future success. Moreover, its management by Simon Property Group, a seasoned player in the retail real estate market, offers expertise that could guide the mall through its next phase.

In a retail landscape increasingly shifting towards experiential shopping, Philadelphia Mills has the opportunity to redefine itself. The mall could focus on attracting tenants that offer unique, experience-based activities, from interactive art installations to virtual reality gaming zones. Such attractions could serve as significant draws, pulling in shoppers and visitors looking for entertainment and leisure activities.

Additionally, the mall’s spacious layout offers room for innovation. From pop-up stores to seasonal markets, the available space could be used to host various events that engage the community and create a buzz around the mall. Such initiatives could also serve as testing grounds for potential long-term tenants, offering them a low-risk opportunity to gauge consumer interest.

In conclusion, Philadelphia Mills has seen better days but is far from a lost cause. With strategic planning, innovative tenant mix, and community engagement, the mall has the potential to turn the tide and reclaim its status as a premier shopping and entertainment destination in Philadelphia, PA.

Comments: 2
  1. Avatar of Jackie

    it needs to come down nothing but trouble for years now! :evil:

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      The mall’s condition has been a point of contention for years, and your voice adds weight to the call for change. Thank you for sharing.

Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: