A Place You Knew Before You Knew Its Name
Before Tilt Studio, before Five Below, before Hobby Lobby moved in, there was just the mall. Sandusky Mall. It opened in 1977 and was known to locals before it even had a full sign-up. It started as a basic plan in late 1976 and quickly grew into something that pulled shoppers from more than one county over.
For people who grew up near Lake Erie, it was one of the few indoor public places where you could walk for an hour, get warm, and maybe pick up a soft pretzel or a school hoodie.
What changed and what hasn’t depends on how far back you go.
A lot of people remember JCPenney and Woolworth’s, but few remember how quickly things started moving even before those doors first opened.
The mall’s story doesn’t begin with decline or renovation plans. It starts with construction crews, winter frost, and retail leases signed in a rush. And if you’re looking for things to do in Sandusky, Ohio, this place is still part of the answer.
Early Market Buildout and Lease Activity (1976–1977)
The property that would become Sandusky Mall moved from concept to construction in 1976, with leases inked before the full structure had walls.
Local newspapers at the time recorded a staggered opening process: stores trickled in as finishing work continued, and by early 1977, about ten tenants were already inside operating.
The grand opening followed in April that same year.
The mall launched with a full slate of anchors. JCPenney was a draw, as expected, but so were The May Company, Woolworth’s, and a local department chain operating under Cohn’s.
That Cohn’s space transitioned to Elder-Beerman shortly after opening, giving the mall a second large-format clothing and housewares retailer almost immediately.
Montgomery Ward would join the lineup in 1979, rounding out the major box anchors at the time.
From the beginning, the layout was single-level with long walking lanes and centralized parking. The center was designed to serve the wider Erie County region and even drew early traffic from Norwalk, Fremont, and surrounding townships.
Leases filled rapidly, and retailers anticipated volume. The site was also zoned in Perkins Township, not Sandusky proper, which meant fewer municipal hurdles and slightly different utility arrangements.
This initial momentum locked in the mall’s regional retail role before the rise of outlet chains or internet sales.
Anchor Turnover and Box Realignments (1979–2000s)
Montgomery Ward joined the tenant mix in 1979, adding another full-scale department store footprint.
That move completed the mall’s core retail lineup, but the balance shifted again just five years later when Montgomery Ward closed its Sandusky location around 1984.
The space didn’t sit vacant long. By 1986, Sears had opened in its place, a familiar substitution across midwestern mall properties.
The May Company, already operating as one of the mall’s original anchors, shifted under new ownership in the 1990s.
Kaufmann’s replaced the May banner mid-decade after regional consolidation under the May Department Stores Company. Then, in 2006, following Federated’s national restructuring, Kaufmann’s name disappeared too.
That location converted to Macy’s without changing its retail footprint. These transitions marked a broader trend in mall consolidation as department store brands narrowed their portfolios.
Elsewhere on the property, tenants in the outdoor strip experienced just as much turnover. Child World operated in that wing until 1992.
OfficeMax moved into that space two years later, holding until 2005. After a short vacancy, K&K Home Furnishings leased the unit in 2006 and stayed through 2014.
By early 2015, Planet Fitness opened there. Across that stretch of years, the mall’s anchors rotated regularly, but each turnover kept the square footage occupied and commercially active.
Retail Reboots and Layout Conversions (2000s–2010s)
New retail concepts entered the mall in the 2000s, starting with Borders in 2005. The bookstore replaced smaller units and created a different kind of traffic anchor.
It closed in 2011 when the national chain liquidated, and Books-A-Million quickly filled the gap that same year.
Across the concourse, T.J. Maxx opened in 2009 in a mid-size format, adding soft goods and off-price apparel to the mix.
June 2016 marked the end of Sears at Sandusky Mall, closing a 30-year run. Less than a year later, Macy’s shuttered in March 2017.
Then, in late August 2018, Elder-Beerman closed as its parent company, Bon-Ton Stores, liquidated. Three department stores exited within 2 years, a drop that hit every side of the mall’s internal floor plan.
By December 2018, a redevelopment plan was announced to reshape the interior layout and bring in new large-format tenants.
Hobby Lobby was the first major name attached to that shift, confirmed in June 2019. The store opened on March 23, 2020, using a portion of the former Sears footprint.
Shoe Dept. Encore moved to a new location inside the mall in October 2020, as interior walls were repositioned for future tenants and entertainment options.
Multi-Use Development and Anchor Redeployment (2020–2024)
By early 2020, Sandusky Mall was already shifting away from a pure retail strategy. After the three anchor closures between 2016 and 2018, mall ownership began repositioning the site for multi-use potential.
A redevelopment plan filed in December 2018 laid out adjustments to the layout, parking configurations, and the addition of new large-footprint tenants.
Five Below launched with a soft opening on May 30, 2021. Ross Dress for Less followed suit in late 2022, opening its doors on October 30 after an interior fit-out phase that lasted through summer.
Together, those tenants anchored a redesigned wing aimed at off-price and value-focused shoppers.
The largest change came with the announcement of Tilt Studio. Publicly confirmed in February 2024, the project took over roughly 52,000 square feet in the space once held by Elder-Beerman.
Buildout ran through the fall. By December 7, 2024, Tilt Studio opened with a full slate of arcade attractions, laser tag, mini golf, and event rooms. That opening marked the first entertainment-first tenant at that scale inside the mall.
Tenant Expansions and Leasing Activity (2025 and Beyond)
Early 2025 brought an update on Sandusky Mall’s leasing status. Local coverage confirmed that four new businesses had signed leases and would be moving in.
Although specific store names weren’t listed in the early announcements, the tone was practical: smaller-format retail geared toward categories like gifts, accessories, and personal goods.
One store, One Little Blessing, offering books, decor, and gift merchandise, had already opened by late April.
Sweets and Geeks, a regional candy and gaming retailer, announced its planned arrival at the mall. The brand operates hybrid stores combining trading cards, retro candy, collectibles, and apparel. The store has already opened.
Beyond its retailers, Sandusky Mall became an occasional backdrop for civic activity during the spring of 2025.
On April 5, a rally affiliated with the “Hands Off” national campaign gathered along the Milan Road perimeter, close to the mall property but technically a public sidewalk.
Another protest, labeled “May Day” demonstration, took place on May 1 in the same vicinity. Both events were organized through social channels and drew attendees from surrounding counties.
Alongside civic activity, the mall calendar took on more variety. By June 2025, the mall scheduled the “Father’s Day Showdown” wrestling exhibition for June 14.
This event was marketed as a live match held on-site, likely in one of the mall’s flexible-use spaces.
Weekly events under the Camp Marshmallow branding were also listed from June 18 through July 16, structured for youth participation and seasonal foot traffic.
The Neutral Zone Buildout and Studio Relocation
The Neutral Zone, known for its studio work and sci-fi fan film productions, began relocating to Sandusky Mall in late 2024. Multiple truckloads of equipment and set material had already arrived on-site by fall.
The studio took over a former anchor store footprint, giving it access to large-format interior space and year-round temperature control. That feature, unusual in smaller production environments, was cited by the studio as a major asset.
Buildout activity continued through the first half of 2025. Posts on Neutral Zone Studios’ Facebook and Instagram accounts documented ongoing renovations, showing partial sets, electrical updates, and ceiling work.
A promotional video titled “The Eagle Has Landed” announced the project’s Sandusky launch and displayed exterior signage now mounted on the mall’s large roadside billboard.
The project also intersected with other media ventures. In early 2025, Neutral Zone promoted a fan-funded film project titled Hereafter through Indiegogo, tied to the new location.
No fixed opening date had been published by June 2025, but the studio was listed in the mall directory as “coming soon.”
🍀