Beaver Valley Mall in Monaca, PA: Adapting to New Shopping Realities

The Birth of Beaver Valley Mall

In 1970, a significant commercial development emerged in Center Township near Monaca, Pennsylvania, reshaping the retail landscape of the Pittsburgh metropolitan area.

The Beaver Valley Mall, a brainchild of the Cafaro Company, opened its doors, introducing a new era of shopping and leisure. This regional shopping mall quickly became a hub for consumers, offering a variety of stores and services under one roof.

Its strategic location on Brodhead Road (PA 18) and accessibility via the Beaver County Transit Authority made it a convenient destination for shoppers from Beaver County and beyond.

The mall’s inauguration began a retail revolution in the area. Prominent department stores of the era anchored it: The Joseph Horne Company, Gimbels, and Sears. These anchors were not just stores but institutions that defined shopping trends and consumer culture.

The presence of these retail giants made Beaver Valley Mall a go-to destination for fashion, home goods, and more. The mall’s early years were characterized by bustling corridors and busy storefronts, a testament to its success and appeal to a wide range of shoppers.

Developers and Ownership Changes

Beaver Valley Mall’s journey has been marked by several changes in ownership and management, reflecting the evolving nature of the retail industry.

Initially developed by the Cafaro Company, a leader in shopping center development, the mall has seen various owners over the decades.

As of December 2023, it is owned by Namdar Realty Group, a significant player in the commercial real estate market.

These changes in ownership have brought different strategies and visions for the mall, each aiming to adapt to the changing retail environment and consumer preferences.

The Beaver Valley Mall’s story is not just about shopping; it’s about the evolution of consumer habits and the transformation of retail spaces.

As we explore things to do in Pittsburgh, PA, the mall’s history offers insights into the broader trends that have shaped shopping malls across America.

Evolution and Expansion of Beaver Valley Mall

Anchor Changes and Additions

Throughout its history, Beaver Valley Mall has witnessed significant changes in its anchor stores, reflecting the dynamic nature of the retail industry.

USA Quiz

How many questions would you like?

Your result:
Comment based on score

After the initial success with The Joseph Horne Company, Gimbels, and Sears, the mall experienced a major shift.

Following a decline in sales in 1986, the Gimbels store was closed and replaced by Kaufmann’s, rejuvenating the mall’s appeal.

This transition was part of a larger trend in the retail sector, where traditional department stores were either evolving or giving way to new players.

Later, in 2006, Kaufmann’s store transitioned to Macy’s, aligning with the broader corporate changes in the retail landscape.

Additionally, JCPenney joined as a fourth anchor in 1998, further diversifying the shopping options available at the mall.

Dick’s Sporting Goods became the fifth anchor in 2007, adding a new dimension to the mall’s retail mix.

Impact on Local Shopping Culture

The Beaver Valley Mall was pivotal in shaping the shopping culture in Beaver County and the surrounding regions. It became a landmark destination for shopping, dining, and entertainment.

The mall’s evolution from a traditional shopping center to a modern retail hub mirrored the changing preferences and lifestyles of the local community.

It was not just a place to shop but a social gathering spot where people came to meet, socialize, and participate in community events.

The mall’s influence extended beyond commerce; it became a part of the area’s social fabric, contributing to the local culture and community identity.

The Chi-Chi’s Hepatitis A Outbreak

The 2003 Outbreak

In 2003, Beaver Valley Mall became the center of national attention for a tragic reason: the largest hepatitis A outbreak in U.S. history.

This health crisis unfolded at the mall’s Chi-Chi’s Mexican restaurant, where 660 people contracted the virus, and four tragically lost their lives.

The outbreak occurred during October and November, typically bustling with shoppers and diners.

This incident affected the restaurant and cast a shadow over the entire mall, particularly impacting the complex’s food court and other dining establishments.

Investigation and Aftermath

The outbreak led to an extensive investigation to identify the source of the virus. It was eventually discovered that scallions imported from Mexico were the cause.

This finding had far-reaching consequences for Chi-Chi’s and food safety practices in the industry.

The outbreak resulted in the closure of Chi-Chi’s locations nationwide, including the one in Beaver Valley Mall.

The incident raised serious concerns about food safety and impacted the mall’s reputation, leading to decreased customer confidence and foot traffic.

Long-term Effects on the Mall

The hepatitis A outbreak had a profound and lasting impact on Beaver Valley Mall. The immediate effect was a decrease in visitors, particularly in the food court area, which had previously been a popular gathering place for shoppers.

In the longer term, the incident contributed to the mall’s declining appeal, as it became associated with a tragic health scare.

This event, combined with other challenges like the rise of online shopping and the departure of major stores, compounded the difficulties faced by the mall in maintaining its status as a premier shopping destination.

Decline of a Shopping Destination

Store Closures and Departures

As the retail landscape continued to evolve, Beaver Valley Mall faced a series of store closures and departures that further contributed to its decline.

Notable closures included Sears’ departure in June 2016, which was part of the company’s broader strategy to phase out traditional brick-and-mortar stores.

Macy’s also announced its exit in 2017, following a decision to focus on their highest-performing locations.

These closures left significant vacant spaces in the mall, diminishing its appeal as a shopping destination.

The loss of these major retailers significantly affected the mall, signaling a shift in the retail paradigm.

Local Perceptions and Comparisons

Locally, the perception of Beaver Valley Mall began to change. Once a bustling center of activity, it came to be seen as a “dead mall” by many in the community.

This sentiment was fueled by the increasing number of empty storefronts and shoppers’ shift to other destinations like Ross Park Mall and The Mall at Robinson.

These malls in more affluent areas offered a wider variety of stores and a more modern shopping experience, drawing away customers from Beaver Valley Mall.

The comparison between these thriving malls and the declining Beaver Valley Mall highlighted traditional shopping centers’ challenges in adapting to new retail trends.

Current Anchors and Their Stories in Beaver Valley Mall

JCPenney: A Long-Standing Retailer

JCPenney, one of the enduring anchors of Beaver Valley Mall, has been a significant presence since its opening in 1998.

The store, originally located in the nearby Northern Lights Shopping Center, moved to the mall to expand its reach and offer a more comprehensive shopping experience.

Over the years, JCPenney has adapted to changing consumer trends, offering a wide range of clothing, home goods, and beauty products.

Despite the challenges faced by department stores nationwide, JCPenney at Beaver Valley Mall continues to attract a loyal customer base thanks to its diverse product offerings and commitment to customer service.

Boscov’s: From Lazarus to a Family-Owned Department Store

Boscov’s, another key anchor, has an interesting history within the mall. The store occupies the space initially held by The Joseph Horne Company, which operated until 1995.

After a series of ownership changes, the location was acquired by Boscov’s and reopened as Boscov’s, a family-owned department store known for its wide selection of merchandise and community involvement.

Boscov’s has managed to maintain its relevance by offering various products, from clothing and accessories to home furnishings, catering to a broad demographic.

Rural King: A New Addition with a Unique Offering

Rural King, a store catering to the farming community’s and general consumers’ needs, opened its doors in the mall in 2018.

Occupying the space formerly held by Sears, Rural King brought a new dimension to the mall’s retail mix. The store offers a range of products, including farm supplies, tools, pet supplies, and outdoor goods.

Its presence in the mall signifies a shift in the tenant mix, reflecting the changing retail landscape and consumer preferences.

Dick’s Sporting Goods: A Destination for Sports Enthusiasts

Dick’s Sporting Goods, which became an anchor in 2007, filled a significant gap in the mall’s offerings by providing sports apparel, equipment, and outdoor gear.

Located strategically between JCPenney and Boscov’s, Dick’s Sporting Goods has become a go-to destination for sports enthusiasts and fitness-conscious shoppers.

The store’s wide range of products and focus on customer experience has made it a popular choice for mall visitors.

U-Haul Storage Center: An Innovative Use of Space

The U-Haul storage center, a relatively unconventional tenant for a shopping mall, represents an innovative use of space.

This facility, located in the area previously occupied by Macy’s, offers a range of storage solutions catering to the local community’s needs.

Including a storage center within the mall’s premises indicates the evolving nature of retail spaces and the need for malls to diversify their tenant mix to remain viable.

Each of these anchors brings a unique element to Beaver Valley Mall, contributing to its character and appeal.

Their presence and evolution within the mall reflect the broader trends in retail and the need for adaptation and diversification in the face of a changing market.

Bath & Body Works: A Fragrant Oasis

Bath & Body Works, a staple in American malls, thrives in Beaver Valley Mall. Renowned for its extensive range of fragrant body care and home fragrance products, this store has cultivated a dedicated following.

Shoppers are drawn to its ever-changing array of scents, seasonal collections, and attractive packaging.

The store’s ability to create an immersive sensory experience has made it a favorite for gifts and personal indulgence.

Champs Sports: Athletic Apparel and Footwear

Champs Sports is a go-to destination for sports enthusiasts and fashion-forward shoppers alike.

Offering a wide selection of athletic apparel, footwear, and accessories, Champs caters to a diverse clientele looking for the latest sportswear and casual fashion.

The store’s commitment to stocking top brands and the latest trends has become a key player in the mall’s retail mix.

GNC Live Well: Health and Wellness Hub

GNC Live Well addresses the growing consumer focus on health and wellness. Specializing in nutritional supplements, vitamins, and health foods, GNC has become an essential stop for health-conscious shoppers.

The store’s presence in Beaver Valley Mall highlights the increasing importance of health and wellness in the retail sector.

Spencer’s: A Unique and Eclectic Mix

Spencer’s stands out for its eclectic and sometimes edgy assortment of products. Known for its novelty gifts, humorous and pop-culture apparel, and unique accessories, Spencer’s caters to a younger demographic looking for something different.

Its ability to blend humor, entertainment, and retail has made it a unique and popular destination within the mall.

Charleys Cheesesteaks and Chick-fil-A: Culinary Favorites

Charleys Cheesesteaks and Chick-fil-A are beloved for their quick and delicious meal options.

Charleys offers a taste of classic cheesesteaks, while Chick-fil-A is famous for its chicken sandwiches and waffle fries.

Their presence in the food court provides shoppers with familiar and satisfying dining choices, enhancing the overall shopping experience.

These stores, each with a unique appeal and loyal customer base contribute significantly to Beaver Valley Mall’s character.

They offer diverse shopping and dining options and reflect evolving consumer preferences and retail trends.

Future Prospects and Revitalization Efforts

Plans for Revitalization

Amidst its challenges, Beaver Valley Mall plans to revitalize and redevelop. A significant initiative in this direction is the proposed development of The Shops at Beaver Valley Mall.

Announced in 2018, this project aimed to transform the space previously occupied by Macy’s into a vibrant mix of retail, restaurants, and service-oriented businesses.

The vision for this development was to create a more diverse and modern shopping experience that would cater to consumers’ evolving preferences.

However, the COVID-19 pandemic caused delays, and as of 2023, the project has seen limited progress, with Firehouse Subs being the only new addition.

Challenges and Opportunities

Beaver Valley Mall’s journey toward revitalization is fraught with challenges. The changing retail landscape, marked by the rise of e-commerce and shifting consumer habits, poses significant hurdles.

Additionally, the mall must contend with the local perception of being a “dead mall” and compete with other shopping destinations that have successfully adapted to the new retail environment.

However, these challenges also present opportunities. The mall could reinvent itself by focusing on experiences that cannot be replicated online, such as community events, unique local businesses, and entertainment options.

Community Perspectives

The local community’s perspective will play a crucial role in the future of Beaver Valley Mall. For many residents, the mall symbolizes past prosperity and a reminder of shared experiences.

Its success in the future will depend on its ability to reconnect with the community, understand their current needs and preferences, and offer something that resonates with them.

Engaging with local businesses, hosting community events, and creating a space that serves as a community hub could be key to the mall’s revival.


Reflecting on Beaver Valley Mall’s Journey

The story of Beaver Valley Mall is a microcosm of the broader trends in the retail industry. From its inception in 1970 as a bustling shopping destination to its current state facing numerous challenges, the mall’s journey reflects the evolving nature of consumer behavior and the retail landscape.

The mall has seen its share of successes and setbacks, from the early days of thriving business and community engagement to the more recent struggles with store closures and declining foot traffic.

The Mall’s Impact and Legacy

Throughout its existence, Beaver Valley Mall has significantly impacted the local economy, culture, and community.

It has been more than just a shopping center; it has been a social gathering place, a venue for community events, and a landmark in Beaver County.

The mall’s history is intertwined with the memories and experiences of those who visited, shopped, and worked there.

Contemplating the Future

As we look to the future, Beaver Valley Mall’s fate remains uncertain. Its challenges are emblematic of those confronting many traditional malls in the digital age.

However, there is still potential for reinvention and resurgence. By adapting to new retail models, focusing on community engagement, and offering unique experiences, Beaver Valley Mall could become a vibrant and thriving destination again.

The mall’s ability to evolve and reinvent itself in response to changing times will be crucial in determining its place in the future of retail and community life in Beaver County, Pennsylvania.

Bundle your hotel + flight together to save more on your next trip! Book now at Expedia.comp565drvjpn8A99EIBAEG8ADCHCIBI website participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program allows sites to earn advertising fees through links to Amazon products at no additional cost to you. Amazon and the Amazon logo are registered trademarks of, Inc., or its affiliates.

Comments: 10
  1. Avatar of

    It’s very sad that Beaver Valley mall is dead and definitely not an exciting area to go. The museum idea is okay but we need activities for all ages here. Beaver Falls and Beaver Valley mall are very sad areas that need to be updated immediately.

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      Thank you for sharing your thoughts on the current state of Beaver Valley mall. It’s essential to have a community dialogue about revitalizing and enhancing the area for everyone’s benefit. Your idea of providing activities for all ages is a valuable perspective for future development plans.

  2. Avatar of Truth

    This mall is everything but thriving. Its a straight up s… hole. The food court is 2 mediocre shop and a chic fillet. Theres maybe 15 open stores to shop in. The mall consists of buisnesses looking for space not retail stores. Pa unemployment, u haul i think theres a small trade school located there, theres a planet fitness. Those are the types of store you can expect.

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      Thank you for taking the time to voice your concerns about Beaver Valley Mall. Open dialogue is crucial for fostering change to create a more vibrant and thriving community.

  3. Avatar of Ted Murray
    Ted Murray

    I have never seen a mall purposely destroy itself like the management in Beaver Valley Mall has over the last 5 years. Unbelievable :sad:

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      Thank you for sharing your observations about Beaver Valley Mall. It’s always valuable to hear different perspectives on management and the changes over time.

  4. Avatar of

    put in a casino

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      That’s a bold idea! A casino might spice things up, but I wonder how the community feels about it.

  5. Avatar of Ryan

    I want them to put in a toy store in the mall for kids and nice clothes stores forever one and a.nice pet store again. and a cool piano store again. Spencer’s would be nice to have again. :|

    1. Avatar of Spencer Walsh
      Spencer Walsh (author)

      Thanks for your input! I agree that a mix of stores catering to different interests, including a new toy store and a stylish clothing outlet, would be fantastic for Beaver Valley. A piano store sounds like a melodic touch, too.

Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: