Rediscovering Oxford Valley Mall: Retail Gem in Middletown Township, PA

Introduction to Oxford Valley Mall’s Evolution

Oxford Valley Mall, located in Middletown Township, Pennsylvania, has been a significant retail destination since its inception in 1973.

Developed by The Kravco Company and now managed by Simon Property Group, this mall has witnessed numerous transformations over the decades.

Initially home to anchor stores like Gimbels and Bamberger’s, which later became Macy’s, the mall has adapted to the changing retail landscape.

The 1980s and 1990s saw major renovations and expansions, including introducing a food court in 1995, enhancing the things to do in Middletown Township, PA.

However, the 21st century brought challenges, with key stores like Strawbridge’s and Boscov’s closing down.

Despite these setbacks, Oxford Valley Mall has continued to evolve, redeveloping into a mixed-use space, reflecting the current retail and real estate trends.

As of 2024, the mall stands as a testament to the dynamic nature of commercial spaces, adapting to meet the needs of its community and visitors.

The Inception and Early Years of Oxford Valley Mall

The Opening and Initial Development

Oxford Valley Mall opened in 1973, marking a significant development in Middletown Township’s retail landscape.

Developed by The Kravco Company, the mall initially attracted a large crowd with its modern design and diverse store offerings.

Its early years were characterized by a bustling atmosphere, driven by popular anchor stores such as Gimbels and Bamberger’s.

These stores were among the first to bring big-name retail to the area, setting the stage for the mall’s long-term success.

Anchor Stores and Early Appeal

Its anchor stores significantly boosted the mall’s appeal in its early years. Gimbels, known for its wide range of merchandise, and Bamberger’s, later rebranded as Macy’s, were pivotal in establishing Oxford Valley Mall as a shopping destination.

USA Quiz

How many questions would you like?

Your result:
Comment based on score

These stores attracted local shoppers and drew visitors from surrounding areas, enhancing the mall’s reputation as a regional shopping hub.

Design and Layout

The design and layout of Oxford Valley Mall in its initial years were ahead of their time. The mall offered an inviting and convenient shopping experience with a spacious two-story structure.

The architectural design was focused on creating an environment that was not just about shopping but also about socializing and spending time.

Oxford Valley Mall
Dough4872, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Major Changes and Expansions at Oxford Valley Mall

The 1980s Retail Shifts

The 1980s were a period of significant change for Oxford Valley Mall. The decade saw the transition of Gimbels to Stern’s, reflecting the dynamic nature of the retail industry.

Additionally, Bamberger’s transformation into Macy’s in 1986 marked a new era for the mall, introducing a more contemporary and diverse range of products and services.

1990 Renovation and Food Court Introduction

In 1990, Oxford Valley Mall underwent a major renovation, modernizing its facilities and enhancing its appeal.

A notable addition was the introduction of a food court in 1995, replacing the second floor of a former Woolworth store.

This new feature offered shoppers various dining options, making the mall a place for shopping and a social and leisure destination.

Anchor Store Changes in the 1990s

The 1990s continued to be a period of change for the mall’s anchor stores. The replacement of Stern’s by Sears in 1989 was a significant development, bringing in a new customer base and diversifying the mall’s retail offerings.

These changes in anchor stores over the years reflect the mall’s ability to adapt to the evolving retail landscape and consumer preferences.

The 21st Century Challenges at Oxford Valley Mall

Closure of Key Stores

The turn of the century brought significant challenges to Oxford Valley Mall. In 2006, the closure of Strawbridge’s, following its acquisition by Federated Department Stores, marked the end of an era.

This was compounded by the closure of Boscov’s in 2008 due to the company’s restructuring efforts.

These closures represented a significant shift in the mall’s retail landscape, impacting foot traffic and the shopping experience.

Sears’ Departure and Its Impact

Another major blow came with the announcement of Sears’ closure in 2018 as part of a nationwide downsizing due to the company’s Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

The store officially closed its doors in January 2019, leaving Macy’s and JCPenney as the only remaining anchor stores.

This departure signaled a critical point in the mall’s history, highlighting the challenges faced by traditional retail in the digital age.

Current Status with Remaining Anchors

As of 2024, Oxford Valley Mall’s anchor store lineup includes JCPenney and Macy’s. These stores continue to draw customers, but the absence of other major anchors has necessitated rethinking the mall’s strategy and tenant mix.

The mall’s management has been working to adapt to these changes, focusing on diversifying the shopping experience to remain relevant in a rapidly evolving retail environment.

Redevelopment Plans and Community Impact

Simon Property Group’s Redevelopment Proposal

In response to these challenges, Simon Property Group, the mall’s management company, proposed a comprehensive redevelopment plan in 2019.

This plan aims to transform Oxford Valley Mall into a mixed-use center, reflecting the growing trend towards multifunctional retail spaces.

The proposal includes the addition of a 600-unit high-end apartment complex, replacing the former Wanamaker’s and Boscov’s anchor spaces.

Mixed-use Development and New Amenities

The redevelopment plan is not just about adding residential units; it also includes the introduction of new eateries, lifestyle complexes, and refreshed office spaces.

These additions create a more integrated experience, combining shopping, dining, living, and working in one location.

The plan reflects a strategic shift towards creating a community-centric space that meets the diverse needs of modern consumers.

Potential Impact on Local Economy and Community

The proposed redevelopment of Oxford Valley Mall is expected to impact the local economy and community significantly.

The mall is poised to become a central hub for the Middletown Township area by introducing residential units and new businesses.

This transformation is anticipated to boost local employment, increase property values, and contribute to the overall vibrancy of the community.

The redevelopment represents a forward-thinking approach to mall management, adapting to changing consumer behaviors and market trends.

The Mall Today: Tenants and Attractions

Current Tenant Mix

As of 2024, Oxford Valley Mall boasts a diverse range of tenants, catering to various consumer needs.

Key stores include American Eagle Outfitters, H&M, and Forever 21, which continue to attract a younger demographic.

Specialty stores like Build-A-Bear Workshop® and Alternate Dimension Toys add unique shopping experiences.

The presence of tech stores such as AT&T and GameStop reflects the mall’s adaptation to modern consumer trends.

Entertainment and Dining Options

Entertainment and dining have become integral to Oxford Valley Mall’s appeal.

The Regal UA Oxford Valley cinema offers a movie-going experience, while dining options like Charleys Philly Steaks and Auntie Anne’s provide a variety of culinary choices.

The addition of the food court has transformed the mall into a social hub, not just a shopping destination.

Position in Pennsylvania’s Retail Landscape

Oxford Valley Mall holds a significant position in Pennsylvania‘s retail landscape. Despite challenges, it remains a key shopping destination in the region.

The mall’s ability to retain and attract diverse tenants demonstrates its resilience and adaptability in changing retail dynamics.

Transforming Oxford Valley Mall: The Rise of Upscale Apartments

In 2023, Oxford Valley Mall in Middletown Township, PA, underwent a significant transformation.

The project, initiated by CornerstoneTracy, separate from Simon Property Group, marks a major redevelopment effort.

It began in the Summer of 2023 on the former site of Boscov’s and its adjacent parking lot. This construction signifies a transformative phase for the mall, shifting its identity from purely retail to a mixed-use destination.

The first phase of this ambitious project includes the construction of 390 luxury apartments, with the first units expected to be completed in early 2024.

The next phase will add more 220 units. Over 600 apartments, distributed across two multi-story buildings, will feature a parking garage and a range of amenities.

Prospective residents can look forward to a resort-style pool, outdoor kitchen and dining spaces, a club room, media room, fitness center, and dog wash station.

This development is part of a larger plan by Simon Property Group to update the entire 190-acre mall property.

The ongoing construction provides a glimpse into the future of Oxford Valley Mall, showcasing a shift towards a more integrated, community-focused approach.

The construction of these luxury apartments is not just a redevelopment of physical space; it represents a strategic shift in the mall’s role in the community.

As retail trends evolve, Oxford Valley Mall is adapting to meet the changing needs and preferences of its patrons and the broader community.

Oxford Valley Mall
Oxford Valley Mall” by RARphotography is licensed under CC BY-NC 2.0

Reflecting on Oxford Valley Mall’s Journey

Summarizing the Mall’s Evolution

Oxford Valley Mall’s journey from opening in 1973 to its current state in 2024 is a narrative of adaptation and resilience.

From the early days of bustling retail activity with anchor stores like Gimbels and Bamberger’s to facing the challenges of the 21st century with the closure of key stores like Strawbridge’s and Boscov’s, the mall has continuously evolved.

Its ability to adapt to the changing retail landscape, shifting consumer preferences, and the rise of digital commerce is a testament to its enduring presence in Middletown Township.

Impact of Redevelopment Plans

The proposed redevelopment plans by Simon Property Group, aiming to transform the mall into a mixed-use space, signify a new chapter in its history.

This strategic shift towards integrating residential, retail, and recreational spaces reflects a broader trend in the retail industry, focusing on creating community-centric environments.

The success of these plans could redefine the mall’s role in the community, potentially setting a precedent for other malls facing similar challenges.

Final Thoughts on Oxford Valley Mall’s Significance

As we look towards the future, Oxford Valley Mall stands as a symbol of the evolving nature of retail spaces.

Its story highlights the importance of innovation and adaptability in an ever-changing economic landscape.

The mall’s journey offers valuable insights into retail centers’ challenges and opportunities nationwide.

As it continues to adapt and evolve, Oxford Valley Mall remains a key player in the retail and community life of Middletown Township and the surrounding areas.

Bundle your hotel + flight together to save more on your next trip! Book now at Expedia.comp565drvjpn8A99EIBAEG8ADCHCIBI website participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. This affiliate advertising program allows sites to earn advertising fees through links to Amazon products at no additional cost to you. Amazon and the Amazon logo are registered trademarks of, Inc., or its affiliates.

Add a comment

;-) :| :x :twisted: :smile: :shock: :sad: :roll: :razz: :oops: :o :mrgreen: :lol: :idea: :grin: :evil: :cry: :cool: :arrow: :???: :?: :!: